At the end of World War II, there was a significant shortage of
locomotives. To quickly address this need, a large number of
locomotives were ordered from major American and Canadian
manufacturers under the Lend-Lease Program, not the Marshall Plan
as is often mistakenly cited. The design was based on the Green Bay
& Western Railroad’s Mikados, modified to meet the requirements of
the French railway, SNCF. These modifications included adjustments
to fit the SNCF loading gauge, European couplers and buffers,
left-hand drive, unique smoke deflectors, and, in some cases, a
Kylchap exhaust system.
The initial order of 700 locomotives was placed in February 1945,
with production distributed among Baldwin Locomotive Works,
American Locomotive Company, and Lima Locomotive Works. A second
order of 640 locomotives followed, which included contributions
from Canadian manufacturers Montreal Locomotive Works and Canadian
Locomotive Company. Most of the second batch were oil burners, a
shift from the coal-fired design of the first batch, driven by
post-war coal shortages and the need for more efficient fuel
use.
The adoption of oil-fired locomotives allowed for significant
savings in coal consumption, which was in high demand, and enabled
a greater operational range—700 km compared to 400 km for
coal-fired engines. This efficiency, however, required substantial
changes in depot operations. The locomotives earned nicknames from
their crews based on their fuel type: “mazoutières” for oil burners
and “charbonnières” for coal-fired engines, with oil burners also
referred to as “les goudronneuses” due to their tar-like
emissions.
After World War II, American manufacturers significantly increased
their production capacity due to the war effort. From July 1945 to
May 1946, they built 700 of the 141 R locomotives in just eleven
months, achieving an impressive production rate of almost three
engines per day at its peak. In contrast, the French locomotive
industry, weakened by the war, took four years (from June 1948 to
July 1952) for Schneider to deliver just 35 locomotives of the 241
P series to the SNCF.
Maintenance of the 141 R Locomotives
Like other steam locomotives, the 141 R required periodic
maintenance based on a well-defined cycle. This included VPL
(Periodic Inspection with Washing every 45 days), VPFA and B (Cold
Periodic Inspection every three months (A) or six months (B)), and
VPP (Periodic Inspections under Pressure) between VPL and VPF.
The 141 R locomotives proved to be particularly economical to
maintain, ranking well ahead of other series in the SNCF fleet.
Maintenance required 27 hours per 1,000 kilometers—20 hours for
routine maintenance, five hours for VPF, and two hours for
intermediate inspections—compared to an average of 50 hours for
other locomotive types. By 1955-1960, this figure had decreased to
22-23 hours per 1,000 kilometers.
Major overhauls involved meticulous inspections of all components,
requiring the separation of the boiler from the wheelset and the
re-profiling of axles when needed. Initially, these overhauls were
scheduled every 120,000 kilometers for locomotives with plain
bearings and 140,000 kilometers for those with roller bearings,
with an intermediate revision (R) midway. The robust construction
of the 141 R allowed these intervals to be gradually increased—by
1958, they were at 165,000 and 185,000 kilometers, and by 1970,
they had reached 175,000 and 200,000 kilometers for locomotives
1101 to 1340. In practice, some locomotives managed to accumulate
up to 230,000 kilometers between major overhauls without
incidents.
In 1948, when the entire fleet was received, 576 major overhauls
were performed, increasing to 715 in 1949. From 1960-1962 onwards,
the number of overhauls gradually decreased, as did the hydraulic
tests on steam equipment, which were combined with major overhauls.
These tests required stripping the boiler and verifying it at a
pressure of 20-24 hpz in the presence of a local mining engineer.
The expiration period for this operation was 10 years for the
boiler and eight years for air tanks, tested at 14 hpz. In
anticipation of the end of steam traction, hydraulic tests and
major overhauls were discontinued in 1968.
Most major repair centers had ceased these operations earlier,
either to focus on maintaining modern equipment or due to permanent
closure. However, several of the 170 locomotives designated for the
cold reserve in 1971 had their service lives extended by undergoing
an RI2 inspection, a type of disguised overhaul, in 1969-1970 at
select depots. This type of revision ended in 1971, with only 35
locomotives receiving treatment. The last significant overhauls
were performed on locomotives 114 and 1099 at Cherbourg in April
1971 and on locomotive 584 at Thouars in May 1971, marking the
final major “surgical interventions” on the 141 R “Liberation”
locomotives.
Service Mileage of the 141 R
Locomotives
The monthly mileage covered by the 141 R locomotives varied
significantly depending on their role and the period in question.
On average, these locomotives regularly covered between 10,000 and
12,000 kilometers per month, but during the summer, peaks of up to
18,000 kilometers were often recorded, particularly in Nice and
Marseille. The coal-fired locomotives generally saw less use
compared to the oil-fired ones, with the latter being more
frequently employed in extensive passenger services, while the
former were primarily used for RA-RO (freight) trains.
To illustrate the decline in service towards the end of their
operational life, here are the total distances covered by the few
remaining 141 R locomotives in 1973 and 1974:
• 1973: Sarreguemines (68,271 km), Le Mans (586 km), Vierzon
(12,380 km), Nevers (41,439 km), Vénissieux (2,786 km), Narbonne
(18,685 km) — Total: 144,147 km.
• 1974: Sarreguemines (8,946 km), Le Mans (586 km), Nevers (522
km), Vénissieux (1,336 km), Narbonne (428 km) — Total: 11,818
km.
For comparison, the total distance covered by these locomotives in
1973 was similar to what a single 141 R in Nice would have covered
in a typical year.
Regarding the total mileage accumulated since their entry into
service, there was considerable variation. The oil-fired
locomotives outperformed the coal-fired ones, having been used more
intensively and decommissioned later. The reasons for these
differences include the location of their operation, fluctuations
in traffic, the nature of the services they performed, extended
downtimes due to accidents or repairs, prolonged storage periods
(sometimes lasting 18 months to two years), and early
retirements.
On average, each of the first 700 coal-fired 141 R locomotives
covered about 1,200,000 kilometers, while the oil-fired locomotives
(numbers 1201 to 1219 and the 20 that were converted to oil in
1956) averaged around 1,500,000 kilometers. More than thirty
locomotives from the 1101 to 1340 series surpassed the
two-million-kilometer mark. The 141 R 1158 from Narbonne holds the
record with 2,464,677 kilometers—more than 60 times the
circumference of the Earth!
The first 141 R locomotive, built by Lima, was completed on July
30, 1945. The first to arrive in France, number 141 R 466, was
unloaded at the port of Marseille on November 17, 1945. The final
locomotive in the series, number 141 R 1340, was completed by the
Canadian Locomotive Company in July 1947 and arrived in France at
the port of Cherbourg on September 5. Tragically, 17 locomotives
(numbers 141 R 1220–1235 and 141 R 1241) were lost at sea when the
Norwegian ship MS Belpamela sank during a storm off Newfoundland on
April 11, 1947. As a result, only 1,323 of the originally ordered
1,340 locomotives were delivered to and entered service with the
SNCF.
The 141 R locomotives represented a significant technological
advancement for the SNCF. The later models (141 R 1101–1340)
featured modern construction techniques, such as Boxpok wheels,
roller bearings on all driving and coupled axles, and a nearly
indestructible one-piece cast steel frame. These features, combined
with the reliable bar frames and axle box bearings in the earlier
models (141 R 1–1100), made these locomotives both powerful and
economical to maintain, with some achieving up to 230,000
kilometers between major overhauls. They were also more comfortable
and user-friendly for the crews, featuring fully enclosed cabs with
ergonomic controls, mechanical coal feeders, and, for the oil-fired
models, simplified operation.
The 141 R locomotives were “banalisées,” meaning they were not
assigned to specific crews, which was a departure from traditional
practices. The last 141 R in service with the SNCF, number 141 R
1187, operated a special run on October 19, 1975, between Lyon and
Veynes. Additionally, four locomotives from the Narbonne depot were
leased to the Hellenic State Railways from November 1973 to April
1974.
Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_Class_141R
In 1961, several 141 R locomotives (R 985, 994, and 1285) were
transferred from Caen to Boulogne to prioritize their use in
hauling auto-train services (GL/LG and FL/LF) on the Boulogne –
Amiens and Calais – Lille routes. These locomotives were chosen
because their exhaust design prevented the projection of cinders
that could damage the transported cars’ exteriors. Meanwhile, the
electrification of rail lines continued, with 25,000 volts reaching
Châlons, Château-Thierry, and powering the short segment of Line 10
between Blesme and Saint-Dizier. As a result, steam operations were
phased out at Metz-Frescaty, Châlons, and Vaires, followed by Creil
and Tergnier under the new electric control.
By 1962, the decline of the 141 R locomotives became more
pronounced. Electrification expanded to key lines, including
Paris-Est – Château-Thierry, Épernay – Reims, Tergnier – Aulnoye,
Béthune – Dunkerque, and Miramas – Marseille. Despite efforts to
reassign locomotives, many were retired, particularly in the East
at Vaires, Châlons, and Reims, and in the North at Tergnier and
Aulnoye. Consequently, storage yards at Amagne and Hirson became
filled with around fifty locomotives placed in long-term storage or
deferred maintenance, with some receiving preservation
measures.
The dominance of the RM (regional management) was no longer
sustainable. After years of receiving locomotives from the
South-East since 1952, several 141 R units from Avignon and Nîmes
were transferred to Le Mans, Nantes, Saint-Brieuc, Grenoble, and
Annemasse. Meanwhile, the overly large locomotive fleets in the
East and North were redirected to the South-East, particularly
benefiting the depots at Dole and Nevers, the latter preparing to
replace Pacific locomotives on the Bourbonnais line.
Sources: https://www.lettreducheminot.fr/materiel/etait-vie-rail-36-fin-141-r/
By January 1, 1963, twelve 141 R locomotives had been officially
removed from the inventory, and about fifty more were out of
service, placed in deferred maintenance. The South-East region now
managed the largest number of locomotives, surpassing the rapidly
declining RM (Regional Management) and the West. Many locomotives
from the East and North regions had already disappeared, and this
trend continued. Nevers became the best-equipped depot with 113
locomotives, followed by Blancarde with 76. The service of 141 R
locomotives was significantly reduced in the East and North
regions, while in the West and South-West, where electrification
had not yet reached, these machines maintained their positions.
In 1964, the 141 R locomotives faced a new challenge: the arrival
of large diesel engines from the 67000 and 68000 series. These
diesels disrupted the operations of the Mikado locomotives on key
routes like Paris – Cherbourg, the Tarentaise, and Lyon – Grenoble.
Environmental concerns in Vierzon led to a switch from coal to
oil-fired locomotives to reduce pollution. The continued
electrification of lines, such as Lille to Hazebrouck and Maubeuge
to Jeumont, further diminished the role of steam locomotives,
leading to their transfer to the South-East or placing them in
storage.
In 1965, the heavy dieselization progressed, particularly in
Auvergne and Dauphiné, where the 141 R locomotives were
increasingly replaced by diesel engines. In Brittany, the
combination of diesel and electric traction made the 141 R
redundant, leading to their reassignment to other depots. By 1967,
the electrification of the Paris – Le Havre line resulted in the
disappearance of steam locomotives from key depots like Sotteville
and Le Havre.
Throughout this period, the number of coal-fired 141 R locomotives
was drastically reduced across all regions. The withdrawal of
oil-fired locomotives also began, particularly in the RM region,
where dozens of units were retired due to the exhaustion of their
service routes and the obsolescence of their boilers. By 1967, with
the continued expansion of diesel and electric traction, the steam
era was rapidly coming to an end, marking the final phase of the
141 R locomotives’ service on the French rail network.
Sources: https://www.lettreducheminot.fr/materiel/etait-vie-rail-36-fin-141-r/
By 1968, the American Mikado 141 R locomotives had become the
dominant steam engines, as all other steam locomotive categories,
such as the 241 P, 150 P, 141 P, 141 C (West), and 141 E/F
(South-East), were phased out, much to the dismay of steam
enthusiasts. The 141 R locomotives continued to operate,
particularly in the East, North, and West regions.
However, the prestige of being the last steam locomotives in
service did little to stop their decline. By January 1, 1968, the
inventory had fallen below 1,000 units, with only 907 locomotives
remaining (447 coal and 460 oil-fired), of which 76 were in
deferred maintenance and unlikely to return to service.
The number of depots housing 141 R locomotives had dropped to 28,
with Nevers still leading with 116 operational engines, followed by
Le Mans with 81, Miramas with 69, and Nantes with 61, though Nantes
was nearing the end of its operations. In 1968, many locomotives
were regrouped to streamline operations and make way for modern
engines. Depots in Nîmes, Grenoble, Nice, Blainville, Laon, and
Nantes were closed as dieselization continued to expand, especially
in the East around Châlons, Nancy, and Strasbourg. A new depot was
established in Chaumont to handle the last remaining 141 R
locomotives.
By 1969, the number of 141 R locomotives continued to decrease
rapidly. The West region consolidated its operations by closing the
depots at Mézidon and Saint-Brieuc. Le Mans, with 108 locomotives,
became the primary hub, covering a large territory alongside Auray.
However, the removal of water and fuel supply points began to limit
the operational range of these locomotives. In the North, the
electrification of the Creil – Épluches – Achères line led to the
closure of the Creil depot. The decommissioning of express services
in Vierzon and Bordeaux resulted in the transfer of additional
locomotives from the RM region, where they were less needed.
In the summer of 1970, the West region decommissioned its
coal-fired locomotives at Argentan and Le Mans, concentrating the
remaining operational engines at the Thouars depot. The
electrification of the Mulhouse to Dole line further reduced the
need for steam, leading to the closure of depots at Mulhouse-Nord,
Belfort, and Dole.
By January 1, 1971, only 484 locomotives remained in service,
including 253 oil-fired units spread across 19 depots. The
dominance of diesel and electric traction continued to grow. The
North region closed the Boulogne depot, maintaining only a cold
reserve of 20 engines at Beauvais. The South-West followed suit,
withdrawing the 141 R from Bordeaux as diesel engines became more
prevalent. In September, steam operations ceased in Annemasse after
the electrification of the line from Bellegarde. By October, the
West region closed its last three steam depots at Le Mans, Auray,
and Thouars. Around the same time, operations ceased at Chaumont
and Miramas, and Nevers reduced its activity to occasional services
to Moulins, Vierzon, Montchanin, and Chagny.
The National Cold Reserve
In response to directives from the supervising ministry, the SNCF’s
Directorate of Equipment and Traction recognized the need to
establish a national cold reserve of 170 locomotives by the end of
1971. These locomotives were to be kept in perfect working
condition to meet any potential needs. By 1970, it became necessary
to reassess future requirements, taking into account the actual
mileage of the machines and the experience gained with heavy diesel
traction.
As of January 1, 1972, a reduction of 20 units was implemented, and
the usable fleet was restructured across selected geographical
centers:
• 70 coal-fired locomotives: 20 in the East at Sarreguemines, 20 in
the North at Boulogne, and 30 in the South-East at Nevers.
• 80 oil-fired locomotives: 25 in the West at Le Mans, 20 in the
South-West at Vierzon, 15 in the South-East at Vénissieux, and 20
in the RM region at Narbonne.
This brought the total to 150 locomotives. The primary advantage of
this policy was the strict limitation on the number of intermediate
overhauls required in 1971. Occasionally, some locomotives from the
cold reserve had to be reactivated to support either other 141 R
locomotives still in intermittent service or thermal traction
needs. This occurred several times in 1972, particularly at
Sarreguemines, Vierzon, Narbonne, Vénissieux, and Nevers, due to
increased traffic during peak travel periods, such as the year-end
holidays, Easter, and the summer season. Additionally, from August
to October, a blockage of the main tracks at Chindrieux in Savoie
led to a slight resurgence in steam locomotive operations from
these depots.
By January 1, 1973, the cold reserve had decreased to 68
locomotives, which were seldom used during that year. In 1974,
further reductions occurred in January and April, leading to the
near-complete dissolution of the reserve by the end of
December.
As of January 1, 1975, only eight 141 R locomotives remained on the
official SNCF roster: R 1187 at Vénissieux and R 1126 at Narbonne,
both granted test extensions and reserved for commemorative or
special trains; and R 754, 802 at Le Mans, along with R 840, 1108,
1163, and 1332 at Vierzon, all approaching the end of their service
life.
Sources: https://www.lettreducheminot.fr/materiel/etait-vie-rail-36-fin-141-r/
By 1972, steam traction had largely disappeared from the French
railways, with the Northern and Western networks having completely
abandoned it. In the East, only a small contingent of 141 R
locomotives remained active at Sarreguemines, where about half a
dozen engines occasionally shuttled to Hausbergen, Béning,
Sarrebruck, and hauled military trains to Bitche in double
traction. The Vierzon depot’s operations were limited to short runs
to Saint-Pierre-des-Corps and Saincaize, and the Nivernaises
locomotives were rarely seen, only operating on the Étang –
Montchanin line. In the Lyon region, the 141 R locomotives at
Vénissieux saw little activity, occasionally leading RO convoys to
Grenoble. Narbonne was the last depot to maintain a regular summer
schedule, handling some freight trains and temporary express
services between Perpignan and Port-Bou.
By January 1, 1973, the inventory of 141 R locomotives had dwindled
to 86, including 42 oil-fired units, with 236 others awaiting
scrapping. The closure of cold reserves at Chaumont and Boulogne,
and the reduction of the reserve at Le Mans, left only a handful of
operational centers: Sarreguemines, Vierzon, Nevers, Vénissieux,
and Narbonne. These depots provided minimal support to diesel
traction, with daily service often involving no more than 21
locomotives across the entire SNCF network, and on some days, none
at all. The era of steam locomotives had effectively come to an
end, with only ghostly appearances of the 141 R in their final
years.
Sources: https://www.lettreducheminot.fr/materiel/etait-vie-rail-36-fin-141-r/
In 1974, the large-scale delivery of 67400 class diesel
locomotives, intended to replace steam traction and provide a more
manageable national reserve, hastened the final decisions regarding
the retirement of the 141 R “Liberation” Mikado locomotives, whose
name had become a distant memory.
As of January 1, 1974, only 61 of these locomotives remained in
service. During the first quarter of the year, only four
locomotives—R 73, 420, 568, and 654—continued to operate in
Moselle, and even then, at a very low frequency. Faced with the
high costs and complexities associated with maintaining steam
operations—such as keeping the locomotives in good working order,
restarting them, reducing facilities, managing specialized
personnel, and addressing technical challenges—the transportation
management decided in late March to further reduce the steam
locomotive fleet. Only about thirty units were kept, primarily for
potential non-commercial uses, such as leasing to third parties for
steam production. However, as these remaining locomotives
approached the end of their service life due to technical
limitations, their numbers dwindled further in the second half of
the year.
On March 28, 1974, after 28 years and four months of service, the
last 141 R steam locomotive, R 73, made its final run on a regular
freight train, hauling RO 51 083 from Béning to Sarreguemines on
the Eastern network. Unlike the celebrated retirement of R 466,
which had been adorned with flags and cheered on by a crowd, this
event passed almost unnoticed.
A few weeks later, the oil-fired R locomotives that had been loaned
to the Hellenic Railways returned to France after covering 211,020
kilometers. Thus ended the remarkable history of the 141 R
locomotives, whose long service was a testament to their
reliability and performance. Their continued operation, long after
other steam engines had been retired, was largely due to their
excellent condition. This marks the conclusion of an extraordinary
chapter in French rail history, where electric and diesel traction
ultimately prevailed.
Sources: https://www.lettreducheminot.fr/materiel/etait-vie-rail-36-fin-141-r/